Post-divorce dynamic’s are extremely emotional. The threat of “I’m taking you back to Court” often has the same effect as a lit match does on gasoline. Sometimes that is exactly the result someone is looking for. The trouble is, that tone is something that Court’s in Maine are getting very tired of.
Our Family Law team fields daily calls from people who want to return to Court with some “new” information that will surely make the judge side with them. We consistently hear comments like, “My husband is an alcoholic” or “my wife is mentally abusive”. Maybe the claims are true, maybe they are exaggerated, but constantly running to court for modifications can get expensive.
The key phrase in Family Law modification is “substantial change in circumstances“. That may sound simple enough, but it is not. Your former partner may have a conviction for Operating Under the Influence and that means they are unfit and unsafe for your children, right? Well, if the conviction did not involve a child in the vehicle, or serious jail time that made the parent unavailable for an extended period, what is the true impact on the child’s well-being? Many normally responsible people make mistakes, and an anecdotal event does not always translate into parental unfitness.
To establish whether there has been a change in circumstances “substantial” enough to warrant a modification of the existing order, the Court will examine how the stated behavior effects the child or children. The legal standard is “the best interest of the child”. Our Family Law team, headed by John Turcotte and myself, has the experience to know when a “problem” warrants judicial intervention and when other less incendiary options will suffice. At Ainsworth, Thelin & Raftice we are always prepared for Court battles, but, more importantly, we know when they are necessary.